NSW - Bow: William Mason, 2: Henry Freeman, 3: Grantley Fitzhardinge, Str; Arthur Fitzhardinge and Cox: C Fitzhardinge
VIC - Bow: H Woolnough, 2: J Bennett, 3: Martin H Irving, Str: J W McCutcheon, Cox: J Williams

John Lang reports this event in his book The Victorian Oarsman published in 1919:

"The earliest boat race between these two Colonies was rowed in 1863 in gigs over a three-mile course on the Parramatta River, N.S.W. The N.S.W. four won (time, 19 min. 25 sec.).

"In this race the crews were of a representative character, and each crew bore the name of its colony. The Victorian crew was made up of members from the Elswick, Melbourne, and Melbourne University Clubs.

"After the race the differences about the amateur status of oarsmen in the two Colonies became accentuated, Victoria alleging the New South Wales crew were to all intents and purposes watermen, having rowed against watermen and for money prizes. The Victorian definition excluded both sorts of oarsmen from amateur competition."

This definition of amateur was to cause disputes in intercolonial competition for many years. Even after a definition was agreed in 1896, the dispute continued with further attempts to rewrite the definition through to WWI.  None of these attempts were successful in gaining the agreement of all States and so the 1896 definition remained.

1st Sydney RC - Bow: Charles de B Deloitte, 2: Grantley H Fitzhardinge, 3: Robert A Clark, Str: Arthur Fitzhardinge, Cox: L McKay, Emerg: John Myers
2nd Parramatta – Bow: F H Williams, 2: Edmund Barton, 3: R B Hayes, Str: John G Blaxland, Cox: J Miller
3rd Hobart Town Light Crew – Bow: W B Jones, 2: H Radcliffe, 3: G Penny, Str: F Norman, Cox: A Humphreys
4th Hobart Town Heavy Crew – Bow: R Barnes, 2: H E Best, 3: C W Gaylor, Str: F W Abbott, Cox: J Hopwood
5th Barwon RC - Bow: E Nichols, 2: Charles Shannon, 3: James F Strachan, Str: J Cullen, Cox: S A Edwards

1872 Intercolonial Fours Start

Acknowledgement to Allport Library and Museum of Fine Arts, State Library of Tasmania

John Lang reports this event in his book The Victorian Oarsman published in 1919:

"In 1872 a race was rowed over a five-mile course on the Derwent River, Tasmania, the Sydney Rowing Club winning against the Parramatta Rowing Club, some Hobart Club crews, and one from the Barwon Rowing Club, the time for the course being 36 min. 30 sec.

"The same year over a 7,000 yard course on Sydney Harbour two crews from the Sydney Rowing Club beat a Victorian crew (of an Intercolonial character, the crew being composed of members of various clubs, among whom were members of the Civil Service, University, and Melbourne Rowing Clubs)."

The race was won by 1/4 mile by Sydney before the Governor and some 20,000 spectators. The Governor presented the winners with 100 sovereigns in a white stain purse embroided by a Tasmanian lady. The Parramatta crew contained our first Prime Minister, Edmund Barton. There was sympathy for the Hobart and Barwon crews who rowed in boats some 50 lb heavier than the Sydney boats.

The Governor’s speech was recorded in the newspapers in the following manner:

"The Governor said he had great pleasure in presenting the prize, which had been so honorably and gloriously won. (Cheers) The case before him contained a cheque for £100, which would be found in a purse made by the fair hands of a Tasmanian lady. (Renewed cheers.) His Excellency congratulated the crew on the victory they had so gloriously won. No doubt there might be a sense of regret that Tasmanians had not carried off the victory in a race on their own waters, but that would not prevent the losers from joining in his congratulations. (Cheers.)

"And he expressed the general sentiment when he said now that the intercolonial races had been so successfully inaugurated, he hoped that they would have the pleasure of welcoming visitors in another occasion, and that the intercolonial race would be an annual event (cheers), in which case he hoped the present winners would be able to add fresh laurels, or that Tasmania would regain more than they had lost. (Cheers)

"It had been calumniously said that Tasmanians did not know how to cheer. But to show that it was a foul calumny, he called upon them to give three cheers at the top of their voices on that occasion for the Sydney Rowing Club. (Three most enthusiastic cheers were then given, with 'one cheer more' several times repeated.) His Excellency then gave the winning crew the purse containing the prize in a glazed case, the purse being tastefully made, and ornamented with flags embroided by the fair hands of a lady as the Governor had stated. He also gave a prize of £20 to the coxswain of the Parramatta crew."

One of the Barwon crew, James Strachan from Geelong, had raced for Cambridge in 1870 winning the Boat Race against Oxford.